What Happens if You Don't Have a Will?
Perceptions
The concept of a will is widely understood. What is not so well understood is what exactly happens if you die without having made one.
Many people assume that their property will automatically pass to their closest family members, particularly their spouse and children. Some believe that a court will decide entitlements among surviving relatives and dependents. Still others believe that the government may take possession of their property.
Even among those who recognize their uncertainty, there is generally little corresponding urgency to resolve it, learn the true consequences of dying without a will, and take steps to avoid them by making one.
For those who do want to know what happens if you don't have a will, a good path to frame the matter is to learn what a will is exactly, what a will does, and then what is the opposite or legally established default in the absence of those things.
Effect
Foundation
Societies across time have recognized the need that a person's wishes regarding the property they possess at the time of their death be respected and carried out after they have gone.
To this end, they have instituted the concept of a will.
A will is a legal document made by a person while they are alive that directs who their property will go to after they die.
Presence
That is the general idea of a will.
In action, the full legal capabilities of a will in Canada are the following:
- It allows a person to choose who their property should be given to after they've died.
- It allows a person to choose the form in which property is given: whether, in the case of adult recipients, it is to be given to them outright or as a trust.
- It allows a person to ensure, in the case of minor recipients, that property be given as a trust, to avoid the need to pay it into court if given outright.
- It allows a person to choose who should be responsible for giving their property to the intended recipients after they've died and administering their estate - their executor.
- It allows a person to choose the manner in which their estate is administered: they may grant their executor considerable flexibility and freedoms in how they do so.
- It allows a person's estate to start to be administered immediately since a chosen executor is known.
- It allows a person to choose who their minor children's guardian should be after they've died.
Absence
If a person fails to make a will then they lose out on the ability to make these choices since a will is the sole established means by which to make them.
Instead, the choices will be made for the person - either as defaults that exist at law or according to a court's opinion.
The following occurs in the absence of a will:
It allows a person to choose who their property should be given to after they've died.A person's property goes only to certain immediate relatives according to a fixed formula.It allows a person to choose the form in which property is given: whether, in the case of adult recipients, it is to be given to them outright or as a trust.A person's property only goes to such a recipient outright. No trusts are made.It allows a person to ensure, in the case of minor recipients, that property be given as a trust, to avoid the need to pay it into court if given outright.A person's property intended for such a recipient who is a minor is instead paid into court. This is according to the requirement to do so when property is to go to a minor outright. The requirement is not avoided since no trusts are made.It allows a person to choose who should be responsible for giving their property to the intended recipients after they've died and administering their estate - their executor.A person's estate is usually only administered by, and their property usually only given out according to the fixed formula by, certain immediate relatives according to a similar formula applied by a court.It allows a person to choose the manner in which their estate is administered: they may grant their executor considerable flexibility and freedoms in how they do so.The court-appointed administrator of a person's estate may only act according to the inflexible default laws in place which often require court oversight and approval.It allows a person's estate to start to be administered immediately since a chosen executor is known.A person's estate may not be administered until a court has finished deciding who should be responsible to do so.It allows a person to choose who their minor children's guardian should be after they've died.A court decides who should be a person's minor children's guardian after they've died.
Comparison
These seven consequences as a table comparison:
| With A Will | Without A Will | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Who Gets Your Property? | You get to choose. You decide which property goes to which people. | You do not get to choose. The choice is made for you - your property goes only to certain immediate relatives according to a fixed formula. |
| 2. | Which Forms Can Your Property Go In? | You get to choose whether each property goes outright (the usual choice) or as a trust fund (a special choice for certain situations). | There cannot be trusts. All property (which already goes to fixed recipients) goes outright by default. |
| 3. | How is Property Intended for a Minor Handled? | With the choice of giving it as a trust instead, the need to pay property into court where it is to be given outright to a minor may be avoided. | Since there cannot be trusts and all property goes outright by default, the need to pay property into court where it is to be given outright to a minor cannot be avoided. |
| 4. | Who is In Charge of Distributing Your Property? | You get to choose the adminstrator of your estate - your executor. | You do not get to choose. The choice is made for you - your estate is usually only administered by certain immediate relatives according to a formula applied by a court. |
| 5. | How does the Process of Distributing Your Property Fare? | You get to grant your executor considerable flexibility and freedoms in the administration of your estate above and beyond the default laws. | You do not get to grant extra flexibility and freedoms. Your court-appointed administrator may only act according to the inflexible default laws in place. |
| 6. | When can Your Property Start to be Distributed? | Your estate may start to be administered immediately since a chosen executor is known. | There is no chosen executor. Your estate may start to be administered only after a court has finished choosing who should be responsible. |
| 7. | Who Gets Custody of Your Children? | You get to express your choice of who should receive custody and care, which is followed. | You do not get to leave behind a choice. A court decides who should receive custody and care, without the benefit of your input. |
The consequences will now be discussed in detail.
In Detail
Who Gets Your Property
Division
Considering that it is the core function of a will, this is the main question that everyone wonders about.
In the making of a will, you get to decide who gets your property.
It may be your nuclear family only. Or, it may not be, if that is more to your liking.
You may prioritize or exclude whomever you wish. You may include more distant relatives, unrelated friends, or charitable organizations.
And, in doing so, you are not limited to referencing your propery only as a whole - you may dictate that so-and-so named property goes to this person, that such-and-such payment goes to that person, and that the remaining whole gets divided among these people... and so on.
Without a will, you will have not made those choices. Entitlements are not established according to your liking.
Instead, the government has a pre-made choice that it applies to you. Entitlements to your estate will be fixed according to their formula.
Statutes
Overall, the law regarding wills in Canada is set at the provincial and territorial level, with each province or territory having their own wills statutes, and in them, their own formula for distributing a deceased person's property on "intestacy" - that is, when they've died without a will.
Formulas
These formulas are similar in their broad structure, though there are differences in operation. A generalized formula may be described as follows:
- Partner: If the deceased left behind a qualifying partner (in some provinces/territories, a legal spouse, while in other provinces/territories either a legal spouse or a "common-law" partner) but no descendants then that qualifying partner receives the whole property.
- Partner & Children, etc.: If the deceased left behind a qualifying partner along with descendants (i.e. children, grandchildren, etc.), then either
- the property is divided among them with the qualifying partner receiving a larger, prioritized portion (specifics based on province/territory) and the descendants receiving equal divisions of the rest according to their branch, or
- in some provinces/territories, under certain family circumstances such as a common, non-mixed family, the qualifying partner nonetheless receives the whole property.
- Children, etc.: If the deceased left behind descendants but no qualifying partner then they receive the property (in equal divisions according to their branch).
- Parents: If the deceased left behind none of the above but did leave behind parents then they receive the property (in halves if both are alive or the whole if only one is alive).
- Siblings, etc.: If the deceased left behind none of the above but did leave behind siblings and/or nephews and nieces then they receive the property (in equal divisions according to their branch).
- Other, Distant Relatives: If the deceased left behind none of the above but did leave some other category or level of distant relatives, such as grandparents, aunts and uncles, cousins, etc., then they receive the property according to the province's/territory's hierarchy on this point.
- Government: If the deceased left behind no relatives then the property "escheats", or goes to the government.
If a person wants to distribute their property in any way that has even the slightest difference than this, they must make a will.
Formation of Trusts
Outright
When a will-maker thinks to "give" something to someone under a will, for the most part it is just that - the item is straightforwardly given: property is made out to a recipient in the terms of the will, and then some short time after the will-maker has passed away, the property, if it is funds, is transferred over to the recipient to use from thereon how they please; if it is personal property, it is handed over to their possession; or if it is real estate in kind, title is transferred to their name, definitively.
This giving of property outright is the common way it is given, arising from the common expectation: people expect to, and mostly do, live out their lives to their life expectancy in their 70s or 80s, after which their property will be intended to go to other mature adults, such as a spouse of similar age, or children well into their 30s or higher.
Trusts
However, you may correctly realize that none of this is guaranteed; you may pass earlier than expected and your property may end up with not yet mature, younger recipients who you don't consider ready to handle large sums on their own.
For this, a will allows you to specify that if a recipient is under a certain age, instead of being given to them outright, the property should be held in a trust fund, to be invested and applied for their benefit responsibly, and only released to them after they finally do reach that age.
With a will, you gain this ability. Without a will, you lose out on it - no trusts are made. Under an intestacy, the default is that property goes outright.
Trust Protection for Minors
When it comes to minor recipients, if property is to be given to them outright, there is a need to pay it into court instead.
Effectively, an ability to give property outright is not there in the case of a minor and is replaced with having to pay it into court.
With a will, there at least remains a choice of specifying a trust fund and avoiding this consequence.
Holding of a minor's intended property in a trust by a chosen executor is a categorically better alternative to payment into court and holding by the government.
Without a will, you lose the ability to avoid this consequence - no trusts are made, all property goes outright by default, and a minor's intended property needs to be paid into court.
Who Distributes the Property
With a will, not only do you get to choose who gets to receive your property, but you get to choose the person who will be responsible for doing the job of transferring the property to the recipients, and otherwise administering your estate - the executor.
In the case of simple estates, it usually makes sense to name the recipients as the executors - those who are set to receive property are often the most appropriate to carry out its transfer.
But that may not always be so, and where there a number of recipients, a will-maker may only want just one or just a few among them to be executor, and not all of them. Or, a will-maker may select as an executor a completely different person who isn't named as a recipient.
It is a consideration of trust and responsibility, and with a will you get to decide.
Without a will, you will have not made this choice. Administration is not established according to your liking.
Instead, a roughly pre-made choice is applied to you. Administration of your estate, which is already going according to a fixed formula, is usually given over to certain immediate relatives according to a similar formula, applied by a court.
The persons so appointed may be not at all whom you might have wanted, which underscores the need to take control with a will.
Ease of Administration
The administration of the estate of a deceased consists of a suite of tasks ranging from routine administrative and record-keeping duties to more consequential matters involving the procuring, management, investment, selling, and transfer of estate property.
With a will, you have the ability to grant your executor wide powers and discretion in carrying out these tasks, above and beyond those available under the default law of estate administration.
The actions and choices of administration as a default are subject to such often impractical strictures as
- requiring the agreement of recipients;
- requiring court approval;
- being limited in duration or scope, or prohibited altogether; and,
- engaging personal liability on the administrator's part despite a good faith purpose.
With a will, these strictures may be relaxed or dispensed with, allowing for a comfortable, effective, and capacious administration by the executor.
Without a will, a court-appointed administrator remains bound by them, making the administration more costly, time-consuming, and cumbersome.
Immediacy of Administration
With a will, the question of who will administer your estate will have been answered by the choice you made and left behind in it.
Your executor derives their authority from the will (in which they were so named) and may begin exercising it immediately to administer your estate.
Without a will, you will have made no choice answering the question of who will administer your estate.
The question then must fall to the court, and administration of your estate may be frozen for weeks or months until the court answers it.
This involves a court proceeding in which administration is usually given over to certain immediate relatives according to a formula. Such an eligible person must file an application and await appointment by the court. Until then, no one possesses the authority to administer your estate. Disagreements over eligibility may further complicate and prolong the process.
That said, an executor under a will is not entirely free from some similar limitations. While their authority derives from the will itself and they may begin the tasks of estate administration immediately, certain higher-level tasks such as transferring land and handling large sums of money in a bank account require a court proceeding known as "probate", in which their authority is granted formal recognition, in order to be carried out.
In any case, the difficulties on this point under an intestacy may be avoided by the clear answer that a choice made in a will provides.
Who Cares for Your Children
While a will by nature concerns property decisions, i.e. who will get your property after you die, family/children's laws allow a person to also express parental decisions within a will, i.e. who will get custody and care of your minor children after you die.
The family or children's law statutes of nearly every province and territory contain a section expressly permitting this.
| Province / Territory | Statute | Sections |
|---|---|---|
| Alberta | Family Law Act, S.A. 2003, c. F-4.5 | s. 22(1)(a) |
| British Columbia | Family Law Act, S.B.C. 2011, c. 25 | s. 53(1)(a) |
| New Brunswick | Guardianship of Children Act, R.S.N.B. 2011, c. 167 | s. 4(1) |
| Newfoundland and Labrador | Children's Law Act, R.S.N.L. 1990, c. C-13 | ss. 68(1) & 68(2) |
| Northwest Territories | Children's Law Act, S.N.W.T. 1997, c. 14 | ss. 43(1) & 43(2) |
| Nova Scotia | Guardianship Act, S.N.S. 2002, c. 8 | s. 19(1) |
| Nunavut | Children's Law Act, S.N.W.T. (Nu) 1997, c. 14 | ss. 19(2)(b)(i) & 43(1) |
| Ontario | Children's Law Reform Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.12 | s. 61(1) & 61(2) |
| Saskatchewan | The Children's Law Act, 2020, S.S. 2020, c. 2 | ss. 4(2)(b) & 45(6)(b) |
| Yukon | Children's Law Act, R.S.Y. 2002, c. 31 | ss. 32(3) & 62(3) |
With a will, not only do you gain the ability to decide which property of yours should go to your children and towards their maintenance, but you gain the ability to decide who should take on the parental role for them.
That said, unlike a property choice, which is absolute, a parental choice is always ultimately subject to court review under some form of a "best interests of the child" standard. Nonetheless, an expressed choice dictates the issue from the get-go and carries great weight where there is to be a review.
Without a will, you will have not expressed such a choice. A court decides who should receive custody and care on its own, without the benefit of your input.
The lack of a known choice leaves room for disputes over eligibility, which may further complicate and prolong the matter.
The potential of a person being appointed who you might not at all have wanted underscores the need to take control with a will.